Stock Market Reaction to the Challenger Disaster

In part II of Chapter One, Surowiecki discusses the stock market reaction to the Space Shuttle Challenger Disaster.  Here is the live CNN broadcast of the shuttle launch.



Here is the extract from the The Wisdom of Crowds that deals with the stock market reaction to the Challenger disaster.
At 11:38 am on January 28, 1986, the space shuttle Challenger lifted off from its launch pad at Cape Canaveral. Seventy-four seconds later, it was ten miles high and rising. Then it blew up. The launch was televised, so news of the accident spread quickly. Eight minutes after the explosion, the first story hit the Dow Jones News Wire. The stock market did not pause to mourn. Within minutes, investors started dumping the stocks of the four major contractors who had participated in the Challenger launch: Rockwell International, which built the shuttle and its main engines; Lockheed, which managed ground support; Martin Marietta, which manufactured the ship's external fuel tank; and Morton Thiokol, which built the solid-fuel booster rocket.
Twenty-one minutes after the explosion, Lockheed's stock was down 5 percent, Martin Marietta's was down 3 percent, and Rockwell was down 6 percent. Morton Thiokol's stock was hit hardest of all. As the finance professors Michael T. Maloney and J. Harold Mulherin report in their fascinating study of the market's reaction to the Challenger disaster, so many investors were trying to sell Thiokol stock and so few people were interested in buying it that a trading halt was called almost immediately. When the stock started trading again, almost an hour after the explosion, it was down 6 percent. By the end of the day, its decline had almost doubled, so that at market close, Thiokol's stock was down nearly 12 percent. By contrast, the stocks of the three other firms started to creep back up, and by the end of the day their value had fallen only around 3 percent.
What this means is that the stock market had, almost immediately, labeled Morton Thiokol as the company that was responsible for the Challenger disaster. The stock market is, at least in theory, a machine for calculating the present value of all the "free cash flow" a company will earn in the future. (Free cash flow is the money that's left over after a company has paid all its bills and its taxes, has accounted for depreciation, and has invested in the business. It's the money you'd get to take home and put in the bank if you were the sole owner of the company.) The steep decline in Thiokol's stock price--especially compared with the slight declines in the stock prices of its competitors--was an unmistakable sign that investors believed that Thiokol was responsible, and that the consequences for its bottom line would be severe.
As Maloney and Mulherin point out, though, on the day of the disaster there were no public comments singling out Thiokol as the guilty party. While the New York Times article on the disaster that appeared the next morning did mention two rumors that had been making the rounds, neither of the rumors implicated Thiokol, and the Times declared, "There are no clues to the cause of the accident."
Regardless, the market was right. Six months after the explosion, the Presidential Commission on the Challenger revealed that the O-ring seals on the booster rockets made by Thiokol--seals that were supposed to prevent hot exhaust gases from escaping--became less resilient in cold weather, creating gaps that allowed the gases to leak out. (The physicist Richard Feynman famously demonstrated this at a congressional hearing by dropping an O-ring in a glass of ice water. When he pulled it out, the drop in temperature had made it brittle.)
In the case of the Challenger, the hot gases had escaped and burned into the main fuel tank, causing the cataclysmic explosion. Thiokol was held liable for the accident. The other companies were exonerated. In other words, within a half hour of the shuttle blowing up, the stock market knew what company was responsible. To be sure, this was a single event, and it's possible that the market's singling out of Thiokol was just luck. Or perhaps the company's business seemed especially susceptible to a downturn in the space program. Possibly the trading halt had sent a signal to investors to be wary. These all are important cautions, but there is still something eerie about what the market did. That's especially true because in this case the stock market was working as a pure weighing machine, undistorted by the factors--media speculation, momentum trading, and Wall Street hype--that make it a peculiarly erratic mechanism for aggregating the collective wisdom of investors. That day, it was just buyers and sellers trying to figure out what happened and getting it right.
Here is a short video of physics professor Richard Feynman giving his evidence to the Rogers Commission.



The Maloney and Mulherin paper is available for download here, with further discussion here.They cannot find an explanation as to how the information about the fault with Morton Thiokol's O-rings came to be reflected in the stock price so quickly. Their conclusion is that this may be a "perplexing situation that while markets appear to work in practice, we are not sure how they work in theory." If they watched a bit of Who Wants To Be A Millionnaire they would be better able to explain this using a simple model of Information Aggregation.

21 comments:

  1. Buying undervalued stocks can not only help garner substantial profits in the future but also downplays the risk involved as you’d not be spending a fortune on buying the stocks. For more please visit http://otcbully.com/value-investing-seeing-a-diamond-where-others-see-graphite/

    ReplyDelete
  2. I must say that You know so much its almost hard to argue with you. Your post is very useful and informative. You shared great information on stock market. keep it up!
    oil trading companies

    ReplyDelete
  3. Where can I get some SGX stock trading signals, along with market analysis..?

    ReplyDelete
  4. Your website is really cool and this is a great inspiring article. Thank you so much.
    easy swing trading strategies

    ReplyDelete
  5. Thanks dear! What I think that buying undervalued stocks can not only help garner substantial profits in the future but also downplays the risk involved. Cheers!
    how to trade shares online

    ReplyDelete
  6. I'd like to take the power of thanking you for that specialized guidance I've constantly enjoyed viewing your blog.life insurance quotes

    ReplyDelete

  7. Your blog is very impressive thanks for sharing such as informations
    Stock Market Quotes : Stockspotify is dedicated to providing the very best online stock trading, market quotes, stocks to own & invest quality products and service.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Yeah ! this is very nice information and very useful free nifty tips !

    ReplyDelete
  9. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Wow Very nice post about stock market reaction ! Nifty maker provides this types of free tips like share market tips, nifty tips and mcx tips !

    ReplyDelete
  11. My brother found Custom Writing Service Evolution Writers and ordered a couple of works. Their customer service is outstanding, never left a query unanswered.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Great post Mark, Thanks! I enjoyed reading it and loved gaining that perspective…. will most certainly pick up that book as well.
    stock market

    ReplyDelete
  13. Great collection of blogs for anyone looking to get into investing! Thanks for sharing
    Crude oil signals
    Indices signals
    Currency signals

    ReplyDelete
  14. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Nice post. Thank you for sharing above information. that is really beneficial for trader as well as investor to being updated with the current market trend is a crucial part of any kind of investment. Equity tips

    ReplyDelete
  16. I have read your blog,its very useful ,Thank you very much
    Stock trading tips

    ReplyDelete
  17. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Asia markets opened lower on Friday, tracking losses in the US from the Thursday session, as Samsung Group shares were in focus following the arrest of its chief.capitalstars

    ReplyDelete
  19. Nice post. It will help all viewer. Go ahead for latest updates of SENSEX, NIFTY and Accurate Intraday Trading Tips. Crude oil signals, Stock market advisory, commodity market advisory

    ReplyDelete